Sunday, 3 November 2013

Class Conference 2013

What is it about train journeys to and from London that are so tiring? No matter. Your humble scribe made the trek down the track for the first annual conference of the Centre for Labour And Social Studies. That's Class to you and me. And, as you might expect, there was a smorgasbord of left, trade union and Labour speakers on offer. Allow me a quick aside. Long time readers will recall a time when I dutifully reported on left gatherings. But more recently, I've stopped. There's only so many times you can go to meetings, come away with the impression that times are hard, and make it sound like something fellow internet travellers might want to read. But yesterday's conference was different. Mixed in with contributions from speakers and the floor about the things we all know we're against was something I seldom hear: practical alternatives. And not just one or two knock offs from The British Road to Socialism, but proper policies with public backing - at least according to this YouGov poll. Unfortunately, for reasons of space I've had to skimp on a lot of detail - I'm pretty sure films of the sessions will make an appearance soon.

The opening rally set the tone. TUC gensec Frances O'Grady roundly condemned the government's attempts to drive unions from public life, starting with Unite. This, she argued, was symptomatic of a certain kind of political economy, one that has no room for working people outside of what they can do to further enrich the wealthy. She also pointed out that this phase of globalisation is not a natural phenomenon, that inequality is not the result of the invisible hand. It is the fruit of certain policy decisions that were taken over these last 30 years. Therefore it's up to the labour movement and Labour Party to counterattack. Frances called for a new left populism resting on three pillars: living standards (higher wages, more better jobs); industrial strategy (a central business bank, workers' representation on company boards); and private ownership (alternatives to, and the "internationalisation" of the ownership of British companies). Angela Eagle with her shadcab hat on talked about the government's rolling back of the social settlement to the Victorian age, and noted divide-and-rule policies and rhetoric, economic dogma, and their reneging on the green consensus. Labour's job therefore is to rebuild positive politics - she called for not only a new economic policy that breaks with austerity, but a new way of measuring performance given how inaccurate GDP figures are. She posed the question of a new society, of getting greater equality and tackling global tax avoidance. She also - significantly? - spoke of the constructive role collective bargaining can play. And lastly, a new politics that can inspire people with hope.

Our third speaker was Doreen Massey of the OU. She talked about how the crisis of neoliberalism hasn't sounded its death knell. As an economic model it completely collapsed in the spectacular implosions of 2008, but politically and ideologically it lingers on. The government clutch it like a mouldy comfort blanket, which in turn is depressing the economy and has seen millions unnecessarily thrown out of work. It therefore must be challenged root and branch. Countering the neoliberal hegemony means asking fundamental questions like "what is an economy for?" and "what role for collaboration, solidarity and care in economics?" Alongside the traditional left defence of the public sector we need to speak out in favour of taxation as a contribution we make toward the good of our community. And we need to reclaim the word 'investment' to mean something that creates value, and purge it of all notions of speculation - which it has latterly come to be identified with. The last turn was Unite's Len McCluskey. He argued that the Grangemouth dispute showed the unlimited power owners have in Tory Britain, the disadvantages unions face and the weakness of politicians. The labour movement and Labour need a programme that can challenge vast inequalities. Standing up to them helps - Len suggested the hysterical comment Unite have attracted is a result of them refusing to go along with the status quo. And the same is true of Ed Miliband's emerging policy agenda. Len specifically singled out the energy price freeze and land policies for praise, but also said this was just a starting point. There are big majorities in the public for the kind of political economy the labour movement favours, particularly around rail and utility renationalisation - but the same polling shows support for austerity and benefit-bashing too. Yet the opening is there.

Conference then moved into break out sessions. I went to the session on green jobs featuring Natan Doran of The Fabians, Mark Rowlinson of the United Steelworkers (Canada), Green Party Leader Natalie Bennett and Red Pepper's Hilary Wainwright. There were all kinds of facts bounced about, from the observation that the "green sector" of the economy is growing at 4%/year and employs almost as many people as the finance industry (Natan), to some new homes being less energy efficient than Victorian buildings (Natalie), to the creation of a "blue/green" alliance by North American trade unions for green jobs (Mark), to the green lessons we can take from the Lucas Aerospace dispute for ecological conversion of production (Hilary). There was a further point Hilary made that I hope to explore in an upcoming post - the idea that capitalism is increasingly having to rely on "knowledge workers" in its ceaseless hunt for profits, and she hinted there's a role for trade unions in aggregating innovation and knowledge in ways beyond its ability to organise.

The session after lunch was a bit ill-fitting I have to say. Various speakers got up and had two minutes to advocate for a particular policy, which was then put to the vote. For what end, and why some policies should be considered worthier than others? Anyway, for you completionists out there we heard pieces for more equalities legislation, the living wage, a living Jobseekers' Allowance, renationalisation of rail, and a steady state economy. A bit like choosing between the strawberry, orange and coffee cremes in my opinion. I took Russell Brand's advice and didn't vote, but it was the trains that got it.

I did consider bingeing on political economy for the afternoon breakout, but the lure of the Twitter celebs pulled me into the session on freedom of the press and social media. We heard from Brian Cathcart of Hacked Off, Clive Lewis (journo and Labour PPC for Norwich South), Tom Watson and Caroline Criado-Perez. I thought Brian's contribution was particularly good as he did some much-needed myth busting around Leveson and the Royal Charter. For example, did our terribly accurate and truth-telling press mention that far from gagging anyone, Leveson favours legislating for a US-style first amendment right to protect free speech? No? Fancy that. How about the panel that would run the new regulatory instrument being independent of politicians and the media industry? Did you see many articles discussing the arbitration service where, if a complainant has a case in law, it would go to the regulator as opposed to the courts thereby saving papers hundreds of thousands in legal fees? Sometimes, some people just don't know what's good for them. Also, Clive discussed the NUJ's support for conscience clauses for journalists, Caroline on the hate campaign she was subject to and Tom Watson on the crisis of the press being symptomatic of a wider crisis in confidence in our institutions; a corrosion, he observed, that only the wealthy and powerful would benefit from.

I shook myself down and asked a question about social media ownership. While we can hold the British press to account how can we expect the same of social media firms who have little infrastructure here and are domiciled in sun-kissed California? Caroline suggested mechanisms of accountability are evolving. The hate she received was just prior to Twitter's flotation, and so it could have affected their share price. Plus they are now very clearly a brand and are subject to pressure as much as any other company that has to live and die by it. Tom replied that we should look into ownership in the longer term. The more pressing question is the ownership of the information we willingly place on social media. Taken as units, each bit of information is harmless. But aggregate them and you have almost complete pictures of individuals that can be used for all sorts of things. And, of course, it's up there forever for future friends, future colleagues, future bosses, and future opponents to use.

Then it was time for the closing rally. Billy Hayes took to the stage to denounce big business's investment strike, and called for Class to become as influential as the Chicago School of neoliberals. Lisa Nandy emphasised the need for solidarity in the face of insecurity, and for policies to tackle it. Mark Serwotka argued that the labour movement had to go beyond rhetoric. What we need is "a movement of the left, not a new party", he concluded. Emily Thornberry previewed some of the Labour policies we can look forward to, if that's the appropriate phrase. And lastly Owen Jones gave a barnstorming speech that forcefully laid Class's stall out as one that is not about sloganising, but offering political alternatives.

All told, the day was a success for Class. That there were plenty of Labour heavyweights knocking about showed that Progress don't have the monopoly on the PLP's preferred go-to for policies any more. But perhaps to avoid the law of diminishing returns, for next year's conference not to be a repeat of this year's perhaps it should take a leaf out of Progress's book and become a membership organisation? Conference could become a proper conference with proper votes. There is certainly the space and appetite for it, so how about it?

NB Comment has to be passed on the guy who was carrying around a two-foot-tall "purple dragon fairy" from session to session. He consistently threw everyone when he got up to speak by introducing his companion and then going on to make reasoned, sensible and sometimes technical points. Most unexpected!

New Left Blogs October/November 2013

A little later than normal, but whatevs. Touch small this month too.

1. #teacherROAR (Unaligned/Education) (Twitter)
2. A Free Left Blog (Labour) (Twitter)
3. Clifford Fleming (Greens) (Twitter)
4. It's Not the Despair (Unaligned) (Twitter)
5. Kate Gilson (Labour) (Twitter)
6. Left Unity Leamington Spa (Left Unity) (Twitter)
7. Matry-sloshed-ka (Unaligned/Feminist) (Twitter)
8. Normfest (Unaligned)
9. Sanchia Alasia (Labour) (Twitter)
10. Socialism First (Labour)

That's your lot for October/November. If you know of any new blogs that haven't featured before then drop me a line via the comments, email or Twitter. Please note I'm looking for blogs that have started within the last 12 months. The new blog round up appears on the first Sunday of every month, and is also cross-posted to Socialist Unity.

Saturday, 2 November 2013

Western Culture and the Third Gender

Well done Germany. German law has been changed to allow for a "third gender", for legal recognition to be extended to people who are born intersex. This is entirely welcome - it's high time the legalities caught up with nature and acknowledged that not all people are born into one of two discrete biological sexes. The BBC report notes this has now created a problem with the law regarding marriage and civil partnerships which are defined in 'traditional' gendered terms. Still, it'll keep the lawyers plenty busy.

One of the interesting asides in the BBC piece is its rundown of 'third gender' recognition. This includes - as you might expect - Thailand, but also Bangladesh, India, Pakistan and Nepal, as well as Australia and New Zealand. With the exception of the Antipodeans, the West are playing catch up. But why? Why is Western culture so hung up on gender? A potted overview of history might help.

The jolly old Judeo-Christian tradition and the cultures it bequeathed have rather set views on gender and the strict differences between women and men. Surprisingly, it wasn't always so. For example, the 12th century Parisian theologian Peter the Chanter and his circle wrote on matters of practical Christian morality, including matters regarding the mediaeval understanding of what we would call gender today. Revealed in his writing was the common sense of his day, that there was less a sense of an absolute separation between the genders and more a continuum or, if you like, a sliding scale ranging from woman to man and back again. However, this did not mean the environs of Notre Dame Cathedral - which Peter oversaw - was a haven of liberal tolerance. On intersex people (or 'hermaphrodites'), he wrote:
The church allows a hermaphrodite - that is, someone with the organs of both sexes, capable of either active or passive functions - to use the organ by which (s)he is most aroused or the one to which (s)he is most susceptible. If (s)he is more active, (s)he may wed as a man, but if (s)he is more passive, (s)he may marry as a woman. If, however, (s)he should fail with one organ, the use of the other can never be permitted, but (s)he must be perpetually celibate to avoid any similarity to the role inversion of sodomy, which is detested by God.
The ambiguity intersexed people presented prevailing theology was defused through a test followed by a prescription. The active/passive injunction was the "natural" way of determining the true gendered character, and once discerned the question was closed down for good. The sliding scale would only allow so much. As an establishment figure, for Peter, ultimately this was always going to be subordinate to his interpretation of received wisdom.

The continuum of gender gradually developed into more rigid notions as the centuries ground on. Intersexed babies tended to be interpreted as monsters, or some sign that parents had incurred God's displeasure. By the 18th and 19th centuries there was a gradual positioning of intersexed bodies as a medical problem. It therefore shifted from the supernatural to the scientific. For example, the 1741 A Mechanical and Critical Enquiry into the Nature of Hermaphrodites by James Parson argued that intersex people as such didn’t exist. He defined true intersexed as people who possessed both fully formed and functional male and female genitalia. Anyone failing to match up to this ideal type were dismissed. While acknowledging this as an anatomical impossibility, he nevertheless argued a person presenting these characteristics should be allowed to choose their gender.

This started a long line of official denialism as far as the medical profession was concerned. But in the context of the rigid gender split, it was better pretend something didn't exist than interfere with the neat precisions of the emergent taxonomy. This was as true in the 19th century, but with an added anxiety. Despite their official non-existence, there was a concern that intersexed people might inadvertently tempt men into homosexual relations. Therefore where the sanctity of marriage was concerned, intersex people were a cause for worry. The early 19th century therefore saw crude attempts to surgically alter intersexed bodies. This mainly involved “freeing” abdominal testicles, in order that there be no gender ambiguity about the physical appearance of human bodies.

As the management of populations became a primary focus of the state, the more rigid the sex distinction became. Birth registration and the assignment of sex was bound up with a whole host of legal rights and obligations specific to sex, and were key to the maintenance of moral communities founded on the family life of the heterosexual marriage. Hermaphrodites were classified as either female or male, and transgression of that gendered binary was severely punished. If it happened, they were typically charged with sodomy, and subjected to a whole host of grisly legal penalties.

Are things that different now? We still have a sense of the discrete “separateness” of gender. We don’t burn intersex people in the street, but we do have a plethora of medical technologies. There is still the assumption that if one is found to be intersex they should then be “corrected”. The relevant NHS website describes the various types of syndromes grouped under ‘intersex’, with advice for patients, parents, and doctors. The NHS provides support for what you might call a 'neonatal psychosocial emergency'. This is the "common sense" perception that a child is at risk of a severe psychological and self-identity crisis if “corrective” surgery isn’t performed prior to the acquisition of a gendered self.

You might call this the 'biomedical argument'. It does not favour surgical intervention because of immediate problems with how an intersex body excretes waste. It demands babies and toddlers go under the knife to give them "normal" bodies.

Unfortunately, this can lead to some very sad outcomes. As well as the case hinted at in the BBC story, some readers may recall the case of David Reimer, who was the subject of an Horizon documentary about a decade ago. David was born biologically male but as the result of a botched circumcision at about 18 months, his penis was destroyed. The doctor recommended to his parents that he be surgically normalised as a girl and be raised as one. They agreed. At the same time, they came under John Money, a child and sex psychologist interested in gender role socialisation. He made recommendations to 'Brenda's' parents, which included strict adherence to gendered modes of dress and self-presentation. To reinforce this, Money forced Brenda and her twin brother, Bruce, to have simulated sex in his office. The theory being this would socialise Brenda into the "passivity" expected of women. This was abuse masquerading as therapy, and it screwed both children up for life.

By the time Brenda reached 13, she had a nervous breakdown and was told about the accident and the "experiment". He renamed himself David and immediately started living as a teenage boy. Unfortunately, the deep scars of their childhood affected the brothers badly. Brian was to die of an overdose, and not long after David took his own life.

While this story is shocking and involves all kinds of abuses of trust, there is a certain commonality to surgeries on intersexed children or boys who find themselves injured like David did. According to Morgan Holmes ('Rethinking the Meaning and Management of Intersexuality’, Sexualities, 5, (2), 159-180. (2002)), 90% of children with ambiguous genitalia who undergo surgery are latterly assigned female. Part of it is deemed to be technical. As the Baltimore surgeon John Gearhart delicately put it, "it is easier to dig a hole than build a pole". But there's more to it than that. There is a history of assumptions around the constitution of masculinity that grounds it in relation to the penis - what sociologists of gender call 'phallocentrism'. If you've got a small one, you're only partially a man. And if you haven't got one at all? The decision surgeons make reflects the received cultural understanding - the absence of a clearly identifiable penis means that intersex child must be classified as a girl, regardless of the character of their gonads or configuration of their chromosomes. Therefore, just like the 18th and 19th century savants, surgery is a sophisticated technology for concealing and hiding intersex people by forcing them into one side of the gender binary.

Perhaps this is starting to break down. With the impressive - and hopefully irreversible - gains made for LGBT rights over the last 30 years and a destabilisation of traditional gender identities, it was only a matter of time before intersexed people came out from the shadows our modern, civilised societies had consigned them in. But intersexed people are challenging they confuse the way we think about gender, and that is a core component of our culture. We recognise multiple gender identities now. Our culture is getting used to the idea of transgendered folk too. But still, whether gay, straight, bi or transitional, everyone fits into the same old gender binary. Germany's welcome move to legally recognise the intersexed will cause the lawyers some issues, but it is the harbinger of a wider cultural conversation that is coming.

Friday, 1 November 2013

By-Election Results October 2013

Party
Number of Candidates
Total Vote
%
+/- Sept
Average/
contest
+/-
Sept
+/-
Seats
Conservative
29
11,749
   22.1%
-10.5%
      405
     +34
   -2
Labour
27
19,317
   36.3%
 +7.9%
      715
   +328
  +4
LibDem
21
  7,077
   13.3%
 +3.9%
      337
   +159
  +1
UKIP
24
  5,596
   10.5%
-10.8%
      233
      -26
    0
SNP*
4
  4,960
     9.3%
 +9.3%
   1,240
+1,240
   -2
Plaid Cymru**
2
    236
     0.4%
 +0.4%
      118
   +236
    0
Green
12
  1,234
     2.3%
  -1.0%
      103
      -11
    0
BNP
3
     115
     0.2%
  -0.2%
        38
      -82
    0
TUSC
1
       21
        0%
 +0.0%
        21
     +21
    0
Independent***
11
 1,171
     2.2%
  -1.9%
      106
      -47
   -1
Other****
14
 1,697
     3.2%
 +2.7%
      121
     +62
    0

* There were four by-elections in Scotland.
** There were two by-elections in Wales.
*** There was only one independent clash consisting of two candidates in a single contest.
**** 'Other' this month consisted of EngDem (32); No Bedroom Tax (446), Christian (60), Communist (35), Solidarity (28), Britannica (19), Scottish Democratic Alliance (1) - all in Glasgow Govan; Pirate (79), Borders (228), Patria (3), Resident (222), Brit Dems Stop Immigration Leave EU (85), Christian (133), Community Action Party (326)

Overall, 53,173 votes were cast over 29 individual local (tier one and tier two) authority contests. All percentages are rounded to the nearest single decimal place. For comparison see September's results here.

These look like a very good set of results for Labour and the LibDems, and pretty awful ones for the Conservatives and UKIP. And that is true. However, once again our friend 'geographical variance' comes into play - in September the shoe was very much on the other foot. This time it's bounced back and balance is restored. Labour and the LibDems have performed well because there were a lot of by-elections in areas where they're strong. The superficially amazing results for the SNP off the back of just four candidates are because Scottish wards are much larger. Hence they piled the votes in for the reds and the yellows too while, of course, north of the border the Tories are dead and UKIP is just a rumour.

The vote averages show a stabilisation for both these parties, and that is particularly a problem for the Tories. Their mean vote is stubbornly below Labour's, even when in months like September's when things went more their way. A partial explanation lies in the Tories standing absolutely everywhere, even when there's zero chance of a half-decent vote and despite their party being in an offensively odious state of decomposition. UKIP, to a lesser extent, are stretching every sinew to stand in every by-election it can. But that can only account for so much. Could there be trouble ahead for the Tories?

NB Those annoyed by the zero percentage awarded TUSC above, 21 votes work out as 0.04% of the total cast and therefore didn't register on my scale that goes to a single decimal place.

Five Most Popular Posts for October

The five most read posts of the month were:

1. Russell Brand and Revolution
2. Socialism for a Sceptical Age
3. A Farewell to Liberal Conspiracy
4. The State Blogging's In
5. Why the Left Hates the Daily Mail

It was always going to be the boy Brand ruling the roost, just edging out my look at Ralph Miliband's "evil legacy". But, as is always the case, what drives audiences are the issues that percolate strongly around the media's hall of mirrors. I noted last month that "straight" pieces of political commentary were finally getting some traction, and this gratifying trend has continued throughout October. Not enough to trouble the top five yet, but give it time. After all, there are only so many people picking over and pondering the actions of the government and opposition front benches.

I'm torn between posts for extra pluggage this last month. 25 Years of the Sega Mega Drive definitely needs a further shout out, because it's the Mega Drive innit. The other? I'll highlight The Sociological Imagination Revisited because the sociological illiteracy our politics displays - on all sides - is deeply, deeply worrying. How can politics hope to be effective if it fights shy of the social forces that makes it possible?